Canada’s legal system is built on a federal framework, meaning law-making powers are divided between the federal Parliament and the provincial or territorial legislatures. Knowing which level of government governs your legal matter for Ontario residents is critical to understanding your rights, obligations, and court process.
The Constitutional Framework
Canada’s Constitution sets the foundation for this division of powers. The Constitution Act, 1867, outlines which matters fall under federal authority and which are provincial. Several sections also provide for shared responsibilities, while the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms limits all governments to ensure fundamental rights are respected.
Key provisions include:
- Charter of Rights and Freedoms (1982): Applies to all levels of government
- Section 91: Federal powers
- Section 92: Provincial powers
- Section 93: Education
- Section 94A: Old Age Pensions & Supplementary Benefits
- Section 95: Agriculture & Immigration (shared powers)
Federal Law – Broad Scope, National Reach
Federal laws apply uniformly across all provinces and territories. While Ottawa creates these laws, their enforcement often involves provincial courts and agencies. Many federal areas have overlapping provincial aspects, making it important to understand both layers of regulation.
Key federal jurisdiction areas under s.91 include:
- Criminal law: Criminal Code, Controlled Drugs and Substances Act (provinces prosecute crimes, but criminal law and procedure are federal)
- Immigration: Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) (federal sets admission rules; provinces can nominate immigrants under Provincial Nominee Programs)
- Banking: Bank Act (federal oversight; provinces regulate lending contracts and consumer protection)
- Trade & commerce: Competition Act, Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (bankruptcy is federal; property rights follow provincial law)
- Intellectual property: Patent Act, Copyright Act (federal jurisdiction; remedies follow provincial procedure rules)
- Employment standards for federal undertakings: Canada Labour Code (applies to banks, interprovincial transport, telecoms, and other federal sectors)
Provincial Law – Ontario’s Jurisdiction
Provinces have extensive authority over property, civil rights, and local matters within their boundaries. In Ontario, these powers influence most day-to-day legal issues, from home renting to employment relationships and estate matters.
Major Ontario jurisdiction areas include:
- Property & Real Estate: Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, Planning Act, Real Estate and Business Brokers Act
- Family law (except divorce): Family Law Act, child protection, custody, and access laws
- Wills & Estates: Succession Law Reform Act
- Civil procedure: Ontario Rules of Civil Procedure (lawsuits, limitation periods)
- Contracts & Torts: Common law + statutes such as Consumer Protection Act, 2002
- Employment: Employment Standards Act, 2000, Occupational Health and Safety Act (except federal sectors)
- Regulated professions: Law Society Act, Regulated Health Professions Act
Federal and Provincial Laws at a Glance
The following table summarises the main differences between federal and provincial law-making powers relevant to Ontario:
| Jurisdiction | Federal Government (Parliament) | Provincial Government (Ontario) |
|---|---|---|
| Criminal Law | Enacts Criminal Code, defines crimes, sets procedures | Enforces criminal laws through provincial courts & prosecutors |
| Immigration | Sets national admission rules under IRPA | Runs Provincial Nominee Program & settlement services |
| Banking | Covers most employees under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 | Regulates lending contracts & consumer protection |
| Trade & Commerce | Oversees national competition & bankruptcy laws | Regulates local business licensing & property transactions |
| Employment Standards | Applies to federal undertakings (Canada Labour Code) | Covers most employees under Employment Standards Act, 2000 |
| Intellectual Property | Administers patents, trademarks, copyrights | Enforces IP rights through provincial courts |
| Family Law | Divorce (Divorce Act) | Marriage, separation, custody, support (Family Law Act) |
| Wills & Estates | Not applicable (provincial area) | Succession Law Reform Act governs wills, estates |
Shared or Overlapping Jurisdiction
Some matters involve both federal and provincial authority. The “pith and substance” doctrine determines which government’s law takes precedence if there is a conflict, while the “double aspect” doctrine allows both to legislate in certain areas.
Examples include:
- Immigration: Federal admission rules + provincial nominee programs
- Agriculture & natural resources: Shared regulation and subsidies
- Environment: Federal controls over fisheries & toxic substances; Ontario regulates emissions & land use
- Health care: Provinces deliver services; federal government sets standards & partial funding
Shared Powers at a glance
| Area | Federal Role | Provincial Role (Ontario) |
|---|---|---|
| Immigration | Sets entry criteria, visas, and deportations | Selects certain immigrants via PNP, funds local programs |
| Agriculture | Sets national standards, trade agreements | Supports local farms, regulates land use |
| Environment | Regulates fisheries, toxic substances, and cross-border issues | Controls emissions, conservation, waste management |
| Health Care | Provides partial funding & Canada Health Act standards | Operates hospitals, regulates health professionals |
| Transportation | Regulates interprovincial & international transport | Oversees local transit, road safety |
Enforcement & Court Structure in Ontario
Although the federal government creates many laws, most are enforced in provincial courts. Ontario’s court system handles the majority of both civil and criminal cases, with certain specialized matters falling under federal court jurisdiction.
The court structure in Ontario contains:
- Ontario Court of Justice: Handles most Criminal Code offences
- Ontario Superior Court of Justice: Broad jurisdiction over civil and criminal matters
- Federal Court of Canada: Exclusive jurisdiction over immigration judicial reviews, IP disputes, and claims against the federal Crown
Hidden Legal Nuances People Miss
Many matters appear to fall under one level of government, but in reality, involve both. Understanding these overlaps can prevent costly mistakes.
For example, the following matters might officially fall under one system, but they usually overlap with the other.
- Divorce vs. separation jurisdiction
- Criminal records and pardons
- Federal bankruptcy laws with provincial property rules
- Employment coverage differences between federal and provincial workers
Conclusion
In Ontario, determining whether a matter is governed federally, provincially, or jointly is crucial for navigating the legal process. Overlapping powers mean that legal advice is often necessary to ensure compliance with all applicable laws.
Sources:
No comment